At first I wasn’t too keen on Clark being some kind of fisherman / drifter type. But it may work. And the breaking the sound barrier part is cool, I guess, but it’s been done before, even by Singer. I did like both VO’s though. What do you all think, gang? Which is the better VO? Sound off!
– Vic @ The Movie Bros.
The Movie Brothers 
I’m not crazy about either one.. the LOTR/Perfect Storm throwbacks made it feel a bit disjointed.
But if I had to choose, I’d definitely go with the Kevin Costner version. At least he’s giving some indication that this movie is about Clark’s journey to define who he wants to be; the Russell Crowe version literally sounds like it was lifted right out of Gladiator.
I see your point about Costner’s VO. Crowe’s is more about his destiny and his inevitability to become Superman. Thanks for reading!
-Vic